Tuesday, March 6, 2018

Slow justice in India (one in a series)

Okay, so last December the High Court in Chandigarh, P.B. Bajanthri, J., set aside a court-martial for vehicular homicide (rash and negligent driving) because the accused, a soldier with 23 years of service, was not informed of the consequences of pleading guilty. Singh v. Union of India, CWP 10501-2010 (O&M) (Punjab & Haryana High Ct. 2017). Fair enough. But consider the chronology:

June 2006, date of offense
June 13, 2006, case referred to the Army by a civilian magistrate
Mar. 30, 2008, general court-martial
Aug. 19, 2008, accused changes plea to guilty
Mar. 30, 2009, sentence adjudged
June 3, 2009, accused discharged from the Army
Feb. 10, 2010, sentence upheld by next higher authority
2010, High Court case filed
Dec. 20, 2017, High Court decision

Seems like a mighty long wait for a 10-page decision in a fairly simple case.

Query for readers in India: why wasn't this case in the Armed Forces Tribunal rather than the High Court?

News from the palace

H.M. Sultan Qaboos
bin Said as-Said
The Times of Oman unhelpfully reports:
His Majesty Sultan Qaboos bin Said on Monday issued a Royal Decree No. 16/2018 introducing amendments to the Military Judiciary Law.

Article (1) introduces the amendments attached (to this decree) to the Military Judiciary Law promulgated by Royal Decree No. 110/2011.

Article (2) cancels all that contradicts the attached amendments or contravenes their provisions.

Article (3) says that this decree shall be published in the Official Gazette and enforced with effect from the day following its date of publishing therein.
Your guess is as good as ours what just happened. It's like publishing an Executive Order amending the Manual for Courts-Martial without the annexes (except we've at least seen those in proposed form).

Monday, March 5, 2018

My Lai Massacre at 50

COL Fred L. Borch, JA, USA (Ret)
For anyone in the DC area or anyone looking for a good excuse to go there, COL (Ret) Fred L. Borch, the Army JAGC Regimental historian is giving a presentation on March 14th at GW Law School titled The History of the My Lai Tragedy and the U.S. Military Justice Response. Here's a link for the specifics.

There's also an operatic performance about the My Lai Massacre, featuring the renowned Kronos Quartet, in Iowa City on March 21. Details here.

Danish Military Justice

The Danish Military Prosecution Service has released the February 2018 edition of its informative introduction to the Danish Military Justice System. You can find it here. Bravo!

Sunday, March 4, 2018

The AFSPA in practice

Lt Gen (R) H S Panag, who served for five years on the Armed Forces Tribunal of India, has this Times of India "Shooting Straight" column describing -- against the backdrop of a particular recent incident from Jammu & Kashmir -- how the Armed Forces (Special Powers) Act functions in deciding whether to prosecute military personnel in civilian or military court. Excerpt:
Human rights violations do take place in an insurgency where force has to be used against terrorists who intermingle with people and enjoy their tacit or coerced support. First, violations may be the result of legitimate and good faith actions. Such cases should and do have the protection of AFSPA. Second, violations stem from overzealous actions of the security forces. These also get the protection of AFSPA from prosecution in civil courts. However, violations of laid down rules of engagement are dealt with under military law. Third, violations are caused by rogue actions. Such cases do not have or deserve the protection of AFSPA. Even in these cases, the courts permit the Army to carry out trial by court-martial.

The Supreme Court has examined the AFSPA in detail in a number of benchmark cases. While it has upheld the legality of the act, it has categorically ruled that the immunity provided to soldiers is only for “good faith” actions and is not absolute. Actions of the troops can be investigated, keeping in view the law of the land, COAS commandments and “dos and don’ts” laid down by the Army. The benchmark judgement given on July 8, 2016 by a three-judge bench examined all aspects in detail and ruled that every allegation of the “use of excessive force” must be investigated. It made the registration of an FIR mandatory in such cases. 
* * *

In all legitimate cases of use of force, police closes the case and it remains on record to avoid future opening of cases, as has happened many times earlier. In controversial cases, the police carries out its investigations and a parallel Court of Inquiry is conducted by the Army. When the chargesheet is filed in court, if both the inquiries are in consonance, that a wrong has been done, the Army takes over the case under Army Act Section 125 and conducts a trial by court-martial. In cases where only the police investigations find that an offence has been committed, the Army informs the court about its own inquiry and invokes AFSPA. In most cases the matter ends there.

In rare cases, the court decides to proceed with the case under the Army Act, Section 126. However, under the AFSPA, central government permission is required to proceed with such cases. This has never been granted up till now. Some cases do linger and go up to the High Court and even Supreme Court. There is not a single case where the Army’s stand has not been upheld. Appearance of individual soldiers in courts is exceptional. The Army has a well laid out procedure to carry such cases to their logical conclusion.
Not one?