Monday, November 16, 2026

Jammu & Kashmir High Court upholds constitutionality of Rule 129 of BSF Rules, 1969

As reported on the Kashmir Observer, the Jammu, Kashmir and Ladakh High Court, India, has upheld the constitutional validity of Rule 129 of the Border Security Force (BSF) Rules, 1969. The aforesaid Rule provides for supply of certified copies of the court martial proceedings to every person tried by a General Security Force Court ("GSFC") at any time after the confirmation of the finding and sentence. A Division Bench of Chief Justice Dr Bhati and Justice Chowdhary allowed an appeal filed by the Union of India and BSF, whereby, it was prayed that the judgment of the Single Bench which struck down Rule 129 as unconstitutional as well as directed GSFC to resume proceedings from the stage of conclusion of prosecution evidence, providing him with relevant copies. 

The accused Constable Rovinder Singh who was tried by a GSFC in the case of the fatal shooting of a Head Constable. The Trial commenced before the Court of Sessions and found Constable Rovinder Singh guilty, sentencing him to life imprisonment and dismissal from service. 

The Division Bench relying on Rule 120 of the BSF Rules, 1969 stated that the right to inspect trial proceedings and other safeguards is sufficiently protected under BSF Act, 1968 and BSF Rules 1969 and clarified that the validity of Rule 129 has no bearing on the final adjudication of the respondents guilt or punishment. Further, the bench relied on the decision of the Supreme Court of India, in Union of India Vs Ex Flt Lt G S Bajwa (2003), which held that the right to inspect court-martial proceedings under the BSF Rules, 1969, at reasonable times satisfies the requirements of natural justice and that there was no occasion for the accused to insist upon daily copies of proceedings. 

The Division Bench also noted that no material was placed on record which could illustrate that the accused was prevented from inspecting the proceedings, cross-examining a material witness or raising a specific defence due to the denial of daily copies of the proceedings. To this end, the bench noted that - “The existence of a possibility that a copy may assist a defence is not sufficient to invalidate a rule which forms part of a special statutory procedure." The Court observed that "our determination of the constitutional validity of Rule 129 rests upon the statutory framework and its safeguards, independently of the merits of the accusation."

No comments:

Post a Comment

Comments are subject to moderation and must be submitted under your real name. Anonymous comments will not be posted (even though the form seems to permit them).