Saturday, March 3, 2018

Why is this former legislator headed for a military trial?

Uganda again. This time the accused is a former Member of Parliament, extradited from Botswana. The Kampala Observer has the story. "[Tony] Kipoi [Nsubuga] was arrested in Botswana in January this year for allegedly posing as a witch doctor and conning millions out unsuspecting Botswanans." He was wanted in Uganda for treason.

The African Charter on Human and Peoples' Rights forbids the trial of civilians by military courts.

Lt Gen (R) Susan Helms on military justice

Lt Gen Susan J. Helms, USAF (Ret)
Lt Gen Susan J. Helms, USAF (Ret) recently gave an interview on being named to the Colorado Women's Hall of Fame. Here's what she had to say about her role as a commander in the administration of military justice:
As a senior officer, I often had responsibilities to lead sexual assault training for the troops. Of course, through the process of executing the training, you learn a lot about the impact on people who have suffered the crime. It was constantly devastating to hear about the stories of victims and what they were put through.

The #MeToo revolution of today has exposed very publicly how the powerful have preyed on the vulnerable, but the phenomenon of sexual predation was something I learned about years ago though my military experience. It became a crusade to figure out how to identify predators in the ranks and root them out. Prevention of the crime through bystander intervention also had tremendous focus.

Later, as a senior Commander, I was very tough on sexual assault within the military court system. I usually elevated every legitimate complaint to a court-martial. It was my strong belief that we needed the full testimony of both the accuser and the accused under oath to understand what happened, and short of a court martial, you often don't get all of the information available. Even though it was always very difficult for all involved, because courts martial are public affairs within the military culture, these types of cases had such a destructive power on people's lives that they were worth the full scrutiny of the law.

In the military justice system, Commanders, not juries, disposition the outcomes of a military trial. A Commander cannot overturn a finding of 'not guilty' but a Commander can reduce the punishment of a 'guilty’ finding or award clemency. In one famous sexual assault case that I had referred to trial, the accused was found guilty in spite of a lack of required judicial evidence. I deliberated for five long weeks, reading every word of the trial record, and ultimately decided not to concur with the guilty finding and levied a lesser charge of ‘Indecent Conduct’ on the accused that carried a lower standard of evidence. It was a searing reminder that our military justice system has to be fair to both the victims and the accused.

Manual changes: continued patience required

The text of the March 1, 2018 executive order prescribing the 2018 amendments to the Manual for Courts-Martial and generally implementing the Military Justice Act of 2016 is now available on the White House website. Unfortunately, the website document does not include the detailed provisions found in Annexes 1 and 2, for which readers will have to wait a few days for the Federal Register version. Until then, no one outside the government will know what, if anything, was changed from the proposed version, which can be found on the website of the Joint Service Committee on Military Justice.

The executive order sets January 1, 2019 as the general effective date of the new provisions. One provision takes effect a little earlier:
Sec. 11. The amendments to Article 146 of the UCMJ enacted by section 5521 of the MJA and the new Article 146a enacted by section 5522 of the MJA shall take effect on the day after the report for fiscal year 2017 required by Article 146(c) of the UCMJ (as in effect before the MJA’s amendments) is submitted in accordance with Article 146(c)(1), but in no event later than December 1, 2018. [Emphasis added.]
Section 10 of the executive order seems to suffer from a layout issue. In the version on the website it appears as follows:
Sec. 10. Except as provided by Rule for Courts-Martial 902A, as promulgated by Annex 2, any change to sentencing procedures:

(a) made by Articles 16(c)(2), 19(b), 25(d)(2) and (3), 39(a)(4), 53, 53a, or 56(c) of the UCMJ, as enacted by sections 5161, 5163, 5182, 5222, 5236, 5237, and 5301 of the MJA; or

(b) included in Annex 2 in rules implementing those articles, applies only to cases in which all specifications allege offenses committed on or after January 1, 2019.
Seemingly the last clause applies to both paragraphs (a) and (b). The provision thus should have been set out as follows:
Sec. 10. Except as provided by Rule for Courts-Martial 902A, as promulgated by Annex 2, any change to sentencing procedures: 
(a) made by Articles 16(c)(2), 19(b), 25(d)(2) and (3), 39(a)(4), 53, 53a, or 56(c) of the UCMJ, as enacted by sections 5161, 5163, 5182, 5222, 5236, 5237, and 5301 of  the MJA; or

(b) included in Annex 2 in rules implementing those articles, 
applies only to cases in which all specifications allege offenses committed on or after January 1, 2019.

New organization of military defense attorneys

A new non-profit has been established in Seattle: the International Association of Military Defense Lawyers. According to its website:
The International Association of Military Defense Lawyers (IAMDL) is the innovation of its founding President and Vice-President, Jocelyn C. Stewart and Will M. Helixon. The organization emerges from a desire to “raise the bar” in military justice practice across all branches of service in all places the military serves, CONUS, OCONUS, within the borders of our nation and on international bases as well. 
Recognizing the absence of a unified professional organization in military defense legal practice, Ms. Stewart and Mr. Helixon saw a void, and formed this organization to help fill it. Defense attorneys perform best when they are unified, interconnected, and driven by a fervent desire, within ethical limits, to use every possible avenue, and leverage every possible benefit on behalf of clients. 
Sensitive to the reality that desire and capability often do not run parallel the International Association of Military Defense Lawyers (IAMDL) wants to utilize the wealth of knowledge, skill, and experience of its board and members to ensure that less seasoned practitioners are best-situated to defend service member clients. IAMDL also wants to ensure that lawyers with little to no experience in military law are properly vetted or trained before they risk the futures of their would-be service member clients. Outside of the military uniformed context, other than simply being licensed to practice law and be in good standing with any state, there are no baseline qualifications required of attorneys before they step into a court-martial. We believe it is time to demand more for Soldiers, Sailors, Airman, Marines, and Coast Guardsman. Moreover, the organization wants to raise the bar for all in the practice, no matter how many years of practice and no matter how many cases any of us has tried; we should all be striving to be better, to stay current, and to ensure the highest caliber of defense for our clients.
The organization is also on Facebook.

"One hell of a February"

The Brookings Institution's Scott R. Anderson has written a detailed and thoughtful appraisal for Lawfare of the state of the Guantanamo military commissions, under the title "Something is Rotten with the State of the Military Commissions." His conclusion:
The military commissions are flawed institutions, crippled by deficiencies in design, uncertainties about their jurisdiction, interagency interference, and their association with a dark history of torture and abuse. If they are to serve a legitimate and effective function, then their use must be marked by visible and principled restraint consistent with other institutions of adjudicatory justice; otherwise, there will be little to distinguish them from the star chambers doling out victor’s justice that critics accuse them of being. We will know the Trump administration’s true agenda for the military commissions in approximately 60 days, when [Secretary of Defense James] Mattis provides his recommendations to the president. That said, its rhetoric thus far shows few signs of embracing this perspective. And to the extent his views have helped to drive recent events, President Trump’s repeated calls for toughening the military commissions may ironically prove to be their death knell.
The essay is particularly useful to those who want to drill down or simply refresh their recollections because of its numerous links to underlying documents and sources.