Monday, November 13, 2017

Prof. Corn interview on the SEAL Team 6 case from Mali

Prof. Geoffrey Corn
South Texas College of Law's Professor Geoffrey Corn's excellent Vox interview about the SEAL Team 6 case out of Mali can be found here. He provides a clear account of the process, including the interservice aspects. Excerpt:
The biggest difference is who decides whether a case gets sent to trial. In most civilian jurisdictions, a prosecutor will recommend a charge to a grand jury — like the Paul Manafort case. The grand jury is going to decide if they think there’s enough evidence to support sending a case to trial.

In the military, prosecutors will advise the commander. But it is the commanding general or admiral who will decide whether or not a case should be sent to a felony-level trial, what we call a “general court-martial.”

The prosecutor doesn’t make that decision. The prosecutor tries the case and makes a recommendation, but the general or admiral isn’t bound by that recommendation. It’s like going to the mayor of your city and asking what cases should be sent to trial.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Comments are subject to moderation and must be submitted under your real name. Anonymous comments will not be posted (even though the form seems to permit them).